Nov 17, 2026 · A note on what this site is for
Why we keep numbers on the officials
Every part of a college football game is measured except one. We know a quarterback’s completion rate on third and long and a kicker’s range into the wind. Nobody publishes what a crew’s flags did to the game. That gap is why this site exists.
It matters more than it used to. Sportsbooks are legal in most states, and prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket now trade college football games the way an exchange trades stocks. In the first four days of this season, prediction markets alone handled about $790 million on college football, according to Covers. The officials on the field are part-time. The money riding on their calls has grown a great deal, and the public record of those calls has not.
That does not mean anyone is doing anything wrong. It means it is worth looking, and worth looking with numbers instead of replays and grudges.
If someone wanted to, how would it work?
We asked that seriously, because the answer tells you where to look.
- Not by picking the winner. An official cannot reliably make a team win. He can lengthen drives or end them, for both teams, and that moves the total score. Called evenly on both sides, it would look perfectly fair on a needle like ours.
- By moving the margin when the result is safe. A late flag in a three-score game can change who beats the betting line without changing who wins, and nobody remembers it on Sunday.
- By not throwing a flag. A call that is never made leaves no record at all.
- In games nobody is watching. A weeknight game between two small programs gets a fraction of the scrutiny of a Saturday night in the SEC.
What we have checked so far
Three things, using data already on this site.
- Do some crews push games toward high or low scores? The differences between crews are no bigger than luck would produce. We only have a handful of games for each crew, so this test cannot see much yet.
- Do late calls that move the margin lean one way? We found 388 flags in 250 games that changed a team’s chance of beating the line while the result was not in doubt. At first they appeared to lean 60 to 40 against the favorite. That turned out to be our own doing: we had only counted the biggest swings, and a favorite that is already covering has more to lose than to gain. Counting every flag in those situations, they split 51 to 49.
- Does the betting line move toward what the calls then do? If someone knew in advance, the money should show it. Across 682 games, lines moved about two points on average between opening and kickoff, and those moves had no relationship to which way the calls went.
None of the three turned anything up. That is a long way from saying there is nothing to find.
What we cannot see
- Which flags were not thrown. We can measure the gap between the calls a game should produce and the calls that were made, and that gap is now part of the needle. We cannot say which play a missing call was on. The spot of the ball, and what the replay booth chose not to stop for, leave no record at all.
- Most crews. We know the officials for 65 of this season’s 751 games, nearly all of them around Texas, where this project started.
- Habit versus luck. One season cannot tell a crew that calls it tight from a crew that had a strange month. That takes several seasons.
What comes next
Officials for every game, not only the ones near Texas. Earlier seasons, to see what carries over from year to year. And the live needle every Saturday, for every team, so the record is made in public as the games are played.
No conclusions yet. We are keeping numbers, and every flag we score is on this site for you to check. This site never claims a game was fixed and never accuses an official.